DOI: 10.55176/2414-1038-2021-4-213-233
Authors & Affiliations
Vereshchagina T.N., Loginov N.I.
A.I. Leypunsky Institute for Physics and Power Engineering, Obninsk, Russia
Loginov N.I. – Chief Researcher, Dr. Sci. (Techn.). Contacts: 1, pl. Bondarenko, Obninsk, Kaluga region, Russia, 249033. Tel.: +7 (484) 399-85-55; e-mail: This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it..
Vereshchagina T.N. – Chief Researcher, Dr. Sci. (Techn.).
Abstract
The paper provides an overview of technical solutions for using of heat pipes in nuclear power plants both developed and operating. The review based on the scientific, technical and patent literature shows wide application heat pipes as heat transfer devices. Using of them for small and super-small power plants seems to be especially effective, because of high specific cost of plants with circulating coolants.
A heat pipe is a device transferrind the heat by means of evaporation and condensation of a coolant circulating automatically under the action of capillar or gravitation forces. Heat pipes are used rather widely, both abroad and in Russia. The first application of a heat pipe principle in nuclear power plants was published in 1957, even before the emergence of the term "heat pipe".
Now, there are about 300 patents in the world related to heat pipes application in nuclear power plants. Theare are seweral thouthands articles on the development of nuclear reactors with heat pipes have been published in the scientific and technical literature.
One should expect that fifth-generation nuclear reactors cooled by heat pipes without any mechanisms and machines for the circulation of the coolant, as well as without the consumption of mechanical and electrical energy, will be appeared in this decade.
Keywords
heat pipe, review, nuclear reactor, coolant, heat transfer, liquid metal, core, thermosiphon
Article Text (PDF, in Russian)
References
- Dunn P.D., Reay D.A. Heat Pipes. Oxford, Pergamon Press, 1976. 272 p.
- Ivanovskii M.N., Sorokin V.P., Yagodkin I.V. Physical Principles of Heat Pipes., Oxford, Claredon Press, 1982, 262 p.
- Fowler T. A Description of the Patent Thermosiphon with Some Modes of Applying it to Horticultural and Other Useful and Important Purposes. London: Longman, Orme, Brown, Green and Longmans, 1829. 40 p.
- Mr. Fowler of Devonshire¢s Mode of Heating by Hot Water. The Gardener¢s Magazine, 1831, vol. VII, pp. 376–378).
- Gaugler R.S. Heat transfer devices. Patent US 2350348, 06.06.1944.
- Gaugler R.S. Capillary heat transfer device for refrigerating apparatus. Patent US2448261, 31. 08.1948.
- Grover G.M, Cotter T.R., Erickson G.F. Structures of Very High Thermal Conductivity. J. Apl. Physics, 1964, vol. 35, pp. 1190–1191.
- Grover G.M. Evaporation-condensation heat transfer device. Patent US3229759, 02.12.1966.
- Ritz H.L. Improvements in or relating to Nuclear Reactors. Patent GB785886, 06.11.1957.
- Atomic Energy Authority. Réacteur nucléaire à réfrigérant vaporizable. Patent FR1362881, 05.06.1964.
- Bohdansky J., Busse C-A., Grover G.M. Système de refroidissement pour réacteurs nucléaires. Patent BE673462, 08.06.1966.
- Busse C.A., Geiger G., Quataert O., Potzschke M. Heat Pipe Life Test at 1600 °C and l000 °C. IEEE Thermionic Specialist Conference, Houston, Texas, 1966, pp. 149–158.
- Termoemissionnoye preobrazovaniye energii. Sb. statey pod red. D.V. Karetnikova, R.Ya. Kucherova, I.S. Mosevitskogo [Thermionic Energy Conversion. Ed. D.V. Karetnikova, R.Ya. Kucherova, I.S. Mosevitsky. Articles Digest. Translated from English]. Moscow, Atomizdat Publ., 1971, 303 p.
- Busse C.A. Issledovaniya teplovykh trubok v Yevrope. In: Termoemissionnoye preobrazovaniye energii. Sb. statey pod red. D.V. Karetnikova, R.Ya. Kucherova, I.S. Mosevitskogo [Studies of heat pipes in Europe. In: Thermionic Energy Conversion. Ed. D.V. Karetnikova, R.Ya. Kucherova, I.S. Mosevitsky. Articles Digest. Translated from English]. Moscow, Atomizdat Publ., 1971. Pp. 206–216.
- Busse C.A., Geyger F., Shtrub K.H., Pettsshke M. Vysokotemperaturnyye litiyevyye teplovyye truby. Termoemissionnoye preobrazovaniye energii. Sb. statey pod red. D.V. Karetnikova, R.Ya. Kucherova, I.S. Mosevitskogo [Thermionic energy conversion. In: Thermionic Energy Conversion. Ed. D.V. Karetnikova, R.Ya. Kucherova, I.S. Mosevitsky. Articles Digest. Translated from English]. Moscow, Atomizdat Publ., 1971, pp. 221–228.
- Deverall J.E., et al. Orbital Heat Pipe Experiment. LA-3714. 1967.
- Deverall J.E., Kemme J.E. Satellite heat pipe. USAEC Report LA-3278. Los Alamos, Scient. Lab. Univ. of Calif., 1970.
- Grover G., Kemmi J., Keddi Y. Uspekhi v tekhnologii teplovykh trubok. Termoemissionnoye preobrazovaniye energii. Sb. statey pod red. D.V. Karetnikova, R.Ya. Kucherova, I.S. Mosevitskogo. Perev s angl. [Advances in heat pipe technology. In: Thermionic Energy Conversion. Ed. D.V. Karetnikova, R.Ya. Kucherova, I.S. Mosevitsky. Articles Digest. Translated from English].]. Moscow, Atomizdat Publ., 1971. Pp. 217–221.
- Wyatt T. A controllable heat pipe experiment for the SE-4 satellite. JHU Tech. Memo APL-SDO-1134, AD 695433. Jons Hopkins Univ., Appl. Phys. Lab., 1965.
- Feldman K.T., Witing G.H. The heat pipe and its potentialities. Engrs. Dig., 1967, vol. 28 (3), p. 86.
- Eastman G.Y. The heat pipe. Scient. American, 1968, vol. 218 (5), pp. 38–46.
- Feldman K.T., Witing G.H. Aplications of the heat pipe. Mech. Engng., 1968, vol. 90, no. 11. pp. 48–53.
- Cotter T.P. Theory of Heat Pipe. USAEC Report LA-3246-MS. Los Alamos, 1965.
- Cheung H. A Critical Review of Heat Pipe Theory and Application. Lawrence Livermore Laboratory, Livermore, Calif., 1968, UCRL-50453.
- Chisholm D. The heat pipe. London: Mills and Boom Ltd., 1970.
- McKechhlie J. The heat pipe: a list of pertinent references. Appl. Heat S.R. BIB. East Kilbride: Nat. Engineering Lab, 1972. Pp. 2–12.
- Ivanovskii M.N., Sorokin V.P., Subbotin V.I., Shustov M.V. Investigation of heat and mass transfer in a heat pipe with a sodium coolant. High Temperature, 1970, vol. 8, no. 2. pp. 299–304.
- Subbotin V.I., Ivanovskii M.N., Sorokin V.P., et al. Investigation of proses in liquid metal heat pipes with complex wick at low vapor tressure. Proc. Int. Heat Pipes Conf. Stuttgard, FRG, 1973. Paper 4-4.
- Mcclure P.R., Dixon D.D., Poston D.I., Mason L. Gibson M. Electric Fission Reactor for Space Applications. Patent US10276271, 2019-04-30.
- Mohamed S. El-Genk, Luis M. Palomino, Timothy M. Schriener. Modular (SLIMM-1.2) reactor. Nuclear Engineering and Design, 2017, vol. 316, pp. 163–185.
- El-Genk M.S., Tournier J-M. E. “SAIRS” – Scalable AMTEC Integrated Reactor Space Power System. Progress in Nuclear Energy, 2004, vol. 45, no. 1, pp. 25–59.
- Fiebelmann P. Reacteur nucleaire heterogene Patent. BE684946, 16.01.1967.
- Fiebelmann P. Nuclear reactor. Patent GB1149946, 23.04.1969.
- Fiebelmann P., N.H. Buzzi U. Nuclear Power Plant for a Space Station. Patent GB122055, 27.01.1971.
- Hampel V.E. Underground nuclear power station using self-regulating heat-pipe controlled reactors. Patent US4851183, 25.07.1989.
- Mcclure P.R., et al. Mobile Heat Pipe Cooled Fast Reactor System. Patent US10643756, 2020.
- Loginov N. Development experience for experimental reactor facility cooled with evaporated liquid metals. Proc. of the Int. conf. on Fast Reactors and Ralated Fuel Cycles: Next Generation Nuclear Systems for Sustainable Development (FR-17). Yekaterinburg, 2017, IAEA-CN245-422.
- Loginov N.I., Mikheyev A.S., Vereshchagina T.N. O razrabotke teplovykh trub dlya YAEU [On development of heat pipes for nuclear power plants]. Voprosy atomnoy nauki i tekhniki. Seriya: Yaderno-reaktornyye konstanty – Problems of atomic science and technology. Series: Nuclear and Reactor Constants, 2021, no. 3, pp. 158–166.
- Huebotter P.R., Mclennan G.A. Fast reactor power plant design having heat pipe heat exchanger. Patent US4560533, 24. 12. 1985.
- Loginov N., Mikheyev A. On Concept of Heat-Pipe Emergency Cooling System for Fast Sodium Fission Reactors. Proc. of the 12th Int. Heat Pipe Conference. Moscow-Kostroma-Moscow, 2002, pp. 444–447.
- Abe S., Koyama Y. Heat Transport Apparatus, and Cooling Device of Reactor Containment Vessel. Patent JP20110123454, 20.12.2012.
- Katsuki Ryoji; Shioyama Tsutomu; Iwaki Chikako; Yanagisawa Naomichi. Heat Transfer Device. Patent JP2015183952, 22.10.2015.
- Nanba Koji; Otsuka Masaya; Fujimura Koji. Nuclear power plant, fuel pool water cooling apparatus, and fuel pool water cooling method. Patent JP201223007, 22.11.2012.
- Wei Chuanqing; Wu Tong; Li Junfeng; Zhang Wenjun; Shuai Jianyun; Xiang Wenyuan; Lv Yonghong; Zhang Shoujie. Heat pipe cooling device for spent fuel water tank of pressurized-water nuclear power station. Patent CN202855320, 03.04.2013.
- Evtikhin V.A; Chumanov A.N. Kosmicheskaya yadernaya ustanovka [Space-based nuclear power plant]. Patent RU2129740, 27.04.1999.
- Boll R.M., Mehdehrehs D.D. Thermionic reactor. Patent RU2159479, 20.11.2000.
- Jarygin V.I; Kuptsov G.A., Ionkin V.I., Ovcharenko M.K., Ruzhnikov V.A., Mikheev A.S., Yarygin D.V. Termoemissionnyy elektrogeneriruyushchiy modul' dlya aktivnoy zony yadernogo reaktora s vynesennoy termoemissionnoy sistemoy preobrazovaniya teplovoy energii v elektricheskuyu (varianty) [Thermionic power-generating module for nuclear reactor core and external thermionic heat-to-power conversion system (alternatives)]. Patent RU 2187156, 10.08.2002.
- Byrd A.W. Thermoelectric power system. Patent US3931532, 06.01.1976.
- Cinotti L., Negrini A. Space propulsion nuclear device. Application EP1748448, 31.01.2007.
- Yuditskiy V.D., Sinyavskiy V.V. Zhidkometallicheskaya sistema okhlazhdeniya [Liquid metal cooling system]. Patent RU2173897, 20.09.2001.
- Yuditskiy V.D., Popov A.N., Popova Ye.L., Sobolev V.Ya., Sinyavskiy V.V. Zhidkometallicheskaya sistema okhlazhdeniya [Liquid-metal cooling system]. Patent RU221331, 27.09.2003.
- Chen-I Lu. Preobrazovatel' energii [Energy converter]. Patent RU2507635, 20.02.2014.
- Gulevich A.V., Zrodnikov A.V., Ivanov Ye.A., et al. Primeneniye yadernykh fononnykh raket dlya issledovaniya dal'nego kosmosa [Application of nuclear phonon rockets for deep space exploration]. Izvestiya vuzov. Yadernaya energetika, 2002, no. 2, pp. 54–62.
- El-Genk Mohamed S., Tournier J-M. P. Reliable and safe thermal coupling of generation-IV VHTR to a hydrogen fuel production complex. Thermal Science and Engineering Progress, 2017, vol. 3,
pp. 164–170.
- El-Genk M.S., Tournier J.-M.P. “SAIRS” – Scalable AMTEC Integrated Reactor Space Power System. Progress in Nuclear Energy, 2004, vol. 45, no. 1, pp. 25–59.
- El-Genk M.S. Review Deployment history and design considerations for space reactor power systems. Acta Astronautica, 2009, vol. 64, pp. 833–849.
- Gibson Marc A., Oleson Steven R., Poston Dave I., McClure Patrick. NASA’s Kilopower Reactor Development and the Path to Higher Power Missions. NASA/TM-2017-219467, 2017.
- Rucker Michelle A., et al. Solar Versus Fission Surface Power for Mars. AIAA 2016–5452, 2016.
- Bryan Smith, Lee Mason, Don Palac, Marc Gibson. Kilopower: Small and Affordable Fission Power Systems for Space. NASA Document ID: 20180000691. Available at: https://ntrs.nasa.gov/archive/nasa/casi.ntrs.nasa.gov/20180000691.pdf (accessed 28.10.2021).
- Oleson Steven R., et al. Kuiper Belt Object Orbiter Using Advanced Radioisotope Power Sources and Electric Propulsion. Proc. of Nuclear and Emerging Technologies for Space 2011, NETS 2011. Albuquerque, 2011, paper 3487.
- Oleson Steven R., Ralph D. Lorenz, Michael V. Paul. Titan Submarine: Exploring the Depths of Kraken Mare. Доступно на: https://ntrs.nasa.gov/api/citations/20150023026/downloads/20150023026.pdf (дата обращения 28.10.2021).
- Loginov N.I.; Pyshko A.P., Mikheev A.S., Denezhkin I.A. Yadernyy reaktor s pryamym preobrazovaniyem energii za predelami aktivnoy zony [Nuclear reactor with direct transformation of energy outside the active zone]. Patent RU2650885, 18.04.2018.
- Arafat Y. eVinci Micro Reactor. Nuclear Plant J., Mach-April 2019, pp. 34–37.
UDC 621.039.52.034.6
Problems of Atomic Science and Technology. Series: Nuclear and Reactor Constants, 2021, issue 4, 4:19
